On Being Forgiven and Forgiving

November 15, 2026

25th Sunday after Pentecost

MINISTER

Rev. David J. Wood

SCRIPTURE

Matthew 18: 15-22; Matthew 6: 12, 14-15


“On Being Forgiven and Forgiving”

by Rev. David J. Wood

25th Sunday after Pentecost, November 15, 2026

First Congregational Church of Camden

Scripture Readings:  Mathew 18:15-22; Matthew 6:12,14-15

Today we take up our next petition in the Lord’s Prayer:

“And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors.”

The story is told of King Frederick II who reigned in Prussia during the 18th Century.  On one occasion he went on an inspection of one of the prisons in his realm.  Prisoners greeted him with pleas for freedom…falling on their knees and declaring their innocence and protesting their unjust imprisonment.

While listening to their pleas…the King’s eyes was caught by a solitary figure off in the corner…seemingly oblivious to all the commotion.

The King made is his way over to the prisoner.

“Why are you here?”

“Armed robbery, your Majesty.”

“Were you guilty?”

“Yes, your Majesty, my punishment is deserved.”

Whereupon, Frederick called for the Prison Warden.
“Release this man at once—I will not have him kept in this prison Where he will corrupt all these fine innocent people!”

To err is human…to deny it is more human.

To blame it on someone else, is even more human.

Confession does not come naturally…it has to be learned and sometimes forced as an admission of last resort.

The high profile story this past week of a certain Tech executive is a case in point.   If confessing our transgressions is hard, I think it is fair to say that practice of forgiveness, forgiving trespasses against us, is even more challenging.

In a CBS 60 Minutes interview just this past week, our President was asked point blank if he would ever forgive his perceived political enemies.

He responded, “The answer is no.”

The interviewer pushed further,

“Before the judgement throne of God?”

The President responded,

“Before the judgment. No, I think they were very bad people and– I dislike, I can use the word hate, I do hate some of my enemies.”

The interviewer, somewhat aghast followed up,

“are you telling me that before the judgment throne of God you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies?  After all that’s been given you?”

“I probably cannot do that, no” the President confessed, “because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.”

Well, I guess we could call that a confessional moment or sorts.  But it is certainly not the kind of confessional moment that is embodied and articulated in the Lord’s Prayer.

Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.

I think it is here, with this petition, that we have come to the counterpoint, the hinge point, the heart of the Lord’s Prayer.

Throughout the Lord’s Prayer,

We call upon God to act:  for God to be God.

God,

Hallow your name

Bring your Kingdom

Do your will

Give us Daily Bread

Forgive our sins

Protect us from temptation

Deliver us from evil…

But HERE and only here, at the very center of the prayer,

It is WE, the ones praying the prayer, who are called up on to ACT.  It is here we EXPLICITLY commit ourselves to act like God.  Here we are committing ourselves to be like God…to mirror God’s mercy towards us in our relationships with one another.

“And Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors”

And just in case we missed this centerpoint,

Jesus adds a reinforcing footnote,

For if you forgive others their trespasses

Your heavenly Father will also forgive. You

But if you do not forgive others—

Neither will your Father forgive your trespasses

Nowhere is the connection between God’s action towards us and our actions towards our neighbors made more strongly than here.  We will never know forgiveness in our lives if we do no make it known THROUGH our lives.

Right away, I can sense the concern being raised:  I thought God’s forgiveness, God’s mercy, God’s love toward us was unconditional.  I’m sensing here an unmistakeable condition….that God will only forgive my sins if I forgive the sins my neighbor has committed against me.

Perhaps this is Hyperbole…many scholars think so…Jesus is known for using hyperbole from time to time…especially when he want to put us religious types on notice.

That being said, I have to admit, this is one hyperbole that I wish Christians had taken literally.   I mean, how different would the world be, how different would the public face of Christianity appear if Christians believed that the forgiveness of their sins was contingent on their practice of forgiveness towards others?

So, I’m not sure I want to move quickly to relieve us of that burden…a burden that Jesus clearly wanted his listeners to feel the weight of. 

You may be asking silently “Are you saying that God’s forgiveness of me depends on my forgiveness of __________  (fill in the blank)?  To which I would answer:  No. I would never say that.  

Jesus is saying that. 

And Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.

Let me say a brief word about the text we read from Matthew 18 which, in many ways, is an elaboration on this petition in the Lord’s Prayer.

In the midst of an extended discourse on forgiveness, Jesus says, “If two of you agree on earth about anything you ask, it will be done for you by my Father in heaven….For where two or three of you are gathered in my name, I am there among you.”

How many of us have heard these verses all our lives…but have failed to associate them with the PRACTICE of forgiveness? 

The chains of reaction that bind us in this world can be broken.  In another verse in our reading from Matt. 18, Jesus says, “Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.”

God, in Christ, has set us free.  Will we chose to act on that freedom on chose to remain captive, and hold others captive, to unforgiveness?

And forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.

Let me be clear, forgiveness is not a simple matter:  There is rarely enough logic (rationale, reasoning) WITHIN a given situation to make forgiveness reasonable, sensible…  It takes a longer, larger memory.  The rationale for forgiveness requires a LARGER FRAME of reference than the offense itself.

The starting place is  not the recognition of the offense…even getting complete clarity on that front can be complicated.  What is not complicated is that God has moved towards us in forgiveness.  That is unambiguous and beyond dispute.  That is the starting point (but not the ending point) for the practice of forgiveness in our lives.  And it is that knowledge, that conviction, that trust that is our reference point, that provides the logic for extending grace, mercy, and forgiveness toward one another.

And so we pray:  And Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.

Let me tell you the story of Jeanne Bishop.

I met Jeanne when she came to speak in my former congregation in Glencoe, Illinois.  Glencoe is the suburb just north of Winnetka where, on April 7, 1990, Jeanne’s sister Nancy (who was several months pregnant) and her husband (Jeanne’s brother in law) were murdered by a teenager.  He had broken into their home…and things went horribly wrong from there.

Jeanne is a Christian…and she struggled with the teaching of Jesus to forgive…what that teaching meant for her in this situation…in the courtroom the murder, 16 year old David Biro, had seemed remorseless, even cocky.  He was sentenced to life in prison with out parole.

But in time, and in conversation with her Pastor, she eventually decided that she must forgive him.  She told her story in a book, Change of Heart: Justice, Mercy, and Making Peace with my Sister’s Killer.

This is how Jeanne put it:  “I really came to the point of forgiveness of him before ever expressing it to him. Just doing it in my own mind and heart, really out of obedience to my faith and in memory of Nancy. Not wanting her memorial to be enshrined in hatred and vengeance. But also for me, because of this notion that hating another person is like drinking poison and expecting that other person to die. I forgave because I wanted to unchain myself from him,”

Let me step aside from Jeannes’ story for a second.   Her story reminds us how forgiveness frees us from being reduced or held captive to the worst in ourselves. 

When we chose to forgive, we decide to no longer hold others captive to their worst selves.

Jeanne’s story reminds us that to forgive is less about the past than about forging a new future.  To risk a new future.  Forgiveness is choosing to break the chain of reaction that locks us and others in a deadening past and forecloses the possibility of a new future.

Nelson Mandela, when he was asked why he was able to forgive and practice mercy towards his transgressors…individuals and government, responded,   “If I had not forgiven, I would still be in prison…and Life is too short to be bitter.”

Back to Jeanne’s story…

While Jeanne, her family, and her friends, knew she had forgiven David Biro, who had been in prison by now for almost 20 years, she had never made direct contact with him.

About that time, she recalls a conversation with a colleague in which she confessed the difficulty of forgiving someone who was, from all appearances, remorseless.  Here colleague questioned her, “How do you know he is remorseless?”

It was only then that she decided to write to the killer, to finally reach out directly to David Biro. 

In the letter she wrote the following: “You’ve heard news of me of how I’ve forgiven you for killing my family members. I never conveyed that forgiveness to you directly. I’m sorry. That was wrong, too. To tell other people and not tell the most important person of all: you.”

Biro wrote back fifteen pages on both sides, telling Jeanne, “I want to take this opportunity to express my deepest condolences and apologize to you.” He concluded his letter by writing, “If my words fall short in their beauty, please know that they were sincere.”

It was only then that Jeanne decided to actually visit Biro.  “It was a very respectful meeting, difficult, that first one, but profoundly healing and helpful,” 

Jeanne and Biro would meet again. And then again. They now meet about every couple months. Jeanne mentioned that she is often asked, “Do you consider David Biro to be a friend?”  Her response:  “Yes, yes, I do.” 

And forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.

Hatred uncomplicates the world—orders, knows all it needs to know.  Hatred simplifies, reduces….nothing more to listen for, look for, hope for..

Forgiveness, on the other hand, complicates the world. 

To confess one’s belief in the forgiveness of sins CUTs

against fatalistic view of the world…of one another…and acts on the conviction that Goodness, redemption, reconciliation remains possible. 

To pray this prayer is to proclaim that the chains of resentment, hate, and indifference, that bind us and with which we bind one another can be broken.

Before I close…I want to draw your attention to a word in the Lord’s Prayer that is easy to pass over, unnoticed.  It is the conjunction AND that connects this petition to the one before.

“Give us the Day our daily bread…AND forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us.”

This experience and practice of forgiveness is as fundamental to our spiritual lives as Daily Bread is to our physical…existence

Forgiveness is NOT a “one an done” thing.  It is a daily practice to which, out of necessity, we return again and again.

And so, together…we pray,

“And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors”

Say it with me:

“And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors”

Amen.  Let it be so…for our sakes and for the sake of the world.

Next
Next

Laity Sunday: 3 Reflections